Ryobi One + Lights: 1800 lumen (PCL630) vs the 3000 lumen (PCL633) ?

[Snap]

Which would be more suitable for general hobby garage use working on vehicles, on the projects workbench, emergency lighting?

I have had halogen floods and some LED headlamps that overwelmed with brightness, so I wondered of the 3000 lumen light would be excessive.

 

[fm2176]

I'd say the 3000 lumens might be overkill for those applications.  I've got some bright lights, including a 10k lumen flashlight, the DeWalt spotlight, and various Milwaukee, Ridgid, and other DeWalt lights, and I find that clarity and position of the beam count for more than sheer brightness.